June 1, 2012

Quebec Bill 33 a step in the right direction: International Open Shop Conference speaker


Bill 33, introduced by Quebec Labour Minister Lise Theriault, is a step in the right direction, but what Quebec really needs to do is get rid of mandatory unionization in the construction industry, according to a speaker at a conference for open shop construction contractors.

Currently, Quebec law takes away two fundamental rights of construction contractors, says Michel Kelly-Gagnon, CEO of Montreal Economic Institute. They currently do not have the right to hire or dismiss workers according to their needs, nor do they have the right to manage their own workforce.

Kelly-Gagnon made his remarks during a breakfast presentation at the seventh annual International Open Shop Conference (IOSC7), produced by Merit Canada and held at the Westin Hotel in Ottawa.

He said Bill 33, which would rescind the power of construction unions to assign workers to job sites in Quebec, is "a step in the right direction."

“Unions determine which workers, and how many workers, will work on a job site especially larger projects in the industrial, institutional and road work sectors,” he said, adding unions can force an employer to hire one worker instead of another of their choosing.

Kelly-Gagon said there are about 30 regulated trades in Quebec.

"Each building trade is connected to union, which jealously protects its domain of competency," he said.

For example, he said, in order to install a simple bathroom, you must have at least eight building trades. One of his researchers was told of a case where a carpenter was given a hammer without claws, because although a carpenter is allowed to hammer nails in, regulations only allow labourers, and not carpenters, to remove nails.

Although the inquiry into corruption into Quebec’s construction industry is making headlines, Kelly-Gagnon said there are other problems, above and beyond alleged kickbacks and alleged ties to organized crime, which harm the economy.

“We hear very little about the regulatory burden that smothers the construction industry,” he said.

Quebec law requires employers in construction to only hire employees who are members of one of the five recognized unions, he said, and this applies to new work in residential, and all work in commercial, institutional and industrial. Only the residential renovation sector is exempt.

“Thankfully, however, in the last few months we have seen some winds of change,” he said. “They are still way too modest in my opinion but nevertheless they represent a positive trend.”

Other speakers at IOSC included Bill Stewart, vice-president of the Merit Contractors Association. He talked about job targeting funds and marketing enhancement recovery funds (MERFs), which are intended to subsidize unionized employers.

Through the provincial Labour Relations Amendment Act, Stewart said Alberta was the first jurisdiction in North America, in 2008, to deal with these funds.

“A MERF is a transfer of what are effectively taxes collected from one group of purchasers of construction to another group of purchases in the public sector, or perhaps a 7-11 store, to unfairly subsidize them,” he said. “These subsidies range anywhere from $5 to $15 an hour and this is a distortion of the marketplace.”

Another issue Alberta dealt with is mandatory ratios of journeypersons to apprentices, he added.

“We are concerned, and I would be from an Ontario perspective, about what is happening with the College of Trades and what the impact may be in terms of apprentice ratios here,” he said. “If you have very high ratios, that can serve as a barrier to bringing young people into the industry and you need new people to enter your industry here in Ontario.”

Print | Comment


VIDEO: The 2014 ACEC BC Awards of Excellence

The Association of Consulting Engineering Companies of British Columbia celebrated its best and brightest at its Awards of Excellence gala, held on April 12 at the Vancouver Convention Centre.

VIDEO: Debate still strong as OCOT turns one

As the Ontario College of Trades celebrates its first anniversary, the regulator body is still a point of contention among several in the province’s skilled trades community.

Journal of Commerce Preview for the week of April 21st, 2014

In this week's preview, we look at some of the stories we'll be covering in the Journal of Commerce for the week of April 21st, 2014.

VIDEO: Brian Hubbs of RDH Building Engineering on insulating concrete forms

RDH Building Engineering Limited is running extensive tests on the viability of using insulated concrete forms (ICF) as walls in building structures. While ICF has traditionally been used below grade, it is becoming possible to also use forms for above-grade work.

Journal of Commerce Preview for the week of April 14th, 2014

In this week's preview, we look at some of the stories we'll be covering in the Journal of Commerce for the week of April 14th, 2014.

VIDEO: BCCGA executive director Dave Baspaly

The British Columbia Common Ground Alliance held a contractor's breakfast on April 1 to highlight the importance of excavation awareness and to ring in "National Safe Digging Month."

Journal of Commerce Preview for the week of April 7th, 2014

In this week's preview, we look at some of the stories we'll be covering in the Journal of Commerce for the week of April 7th, 2014.

A Closer Look VIDEO: ONroute King City service centre redevelopment

Infrastructure Ontario (IO) and Host Kilmer Services Centre have teamed up to redevelop 20 service centres along Highways 400 and 401.

CCA96th: CCInnovations ready to lead the charge

Canadian Construction Innovations (CCInnovations) aims to lead and facilitate the discussion on innovation within the construction industry.


These projects have been selected from 371 projects with a total value of $1,936,826,394 that Reed Construction Data Building Reports reported on Thursday.


$134,000,000 Toronto ON Prebid


$128,250,000 North York ON Prebid


$100,000,000 Toronto ON Prebid

Daily Top 10